Todd Grooms avatar

Todd Grooms

Don't use AI as a Therapist

I have been a longtime listener and subscriber of Accidental Tech Podcast. In the latest member special, ATP Movie Club: Her, the hosts discussed their thoughts after recently watching the 2013 film Her. I never watched the movie, but was vaguely aware that it dealt with the protagonist’s connection with a digital assistant (Γ  la Siri). One of the overarching themes of the episode was the correlations we find ourselves in with respect to the “relationships” people are developing with LLMs. Towards the end of the episode, Marco discussed how people today are beginning to turn to LLMs for companionship or for help (using them as a therapist), eventually postulating current LLMs might be better than a bad human therapist. I have disagreed with many of Marco’s takes on the show, but this one really takes the cake: this is an outrageously bad take. OpenAI’s ChatGPT product has been the focus of lawsuits pertaining to violence and self-harm, for example:

These tools cannot and should not replace human connection or human conversation, regardless of how inadequate a human therapist might be. I have been fortunate to have what I consider to be a good therapist. If I did not feel that way, I would seek out a new therapist. Under no circumstances would I seek out an LLM for this role.

I like ATP and I’m fine with most of Marco’s takes, but this one is in the “Bad Takes Hall of Fame”. We can enjoy using LLMs for software development or for finding utility in repetitive tasks, but we should honestly stop there. This current episode of glazing AI in the tech sphere is getting out of hand.

Finished reading: Wings: the Story of a Band on the Run by Paul McCartney πŸ“š

A Christmas gift from Ashley. I’ve always enjoyed Wings’ music, but wasn’t as familiar with the history of the band. It was a lot of fun. I took the time to listen to the albums after reading about them.

Finished reading: Apple The First 50 Years by David Pogue πŸ“š

A fun read with lots of great stories and anecdotes. I still cannot believe how lucky I am to be apart of Apple and to have Apple be apart of me.

Only the thing for which you have struggled will last.

– Yoruba Proverb

Finished reading: The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas πŸ“š

I had purchased an unabridged copy of this when I was in high school. The book sat on my shelf ever since. Approximately twenty-two years later, I have read it. Well worth the wait. I only regret not reading it sooner.

Finished reading: Superbloom by Nicholas Carr πŸ“š

There is a lot to process here. It can feel a bit overwhelming and deterministic: was our current reality set in motion over a century ago? Can our current situation be improved? I’m feeling less optimistic that it can be fixed.

Finished reading: Source Code by Bill Gates πŸ“š

I really enjoyed the computer history covered in Bill Gates’ memoir. He comes across as a fascinating individual, especially when going into details regarding early software development.

πŸ”— Three Tough Truths About Climate

An interesting and thoughtful prospective about a topic that brings me anxiety. I often fret over my children’s experience with the world and what the climate will be like in their lifetime. Instead of feeling hopeless, this made me feel a little more hopeful.